domestic violence defense attorney

September 13, 2025

Can Self-Defense Be Used in a Florida Domestic Violence Case?

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

When emotions run high in domestic disputes, situations can escalate quickly from verbal arguments to physical confrontations. If you’ve been arrested for domestic violence in Florida after defending yourself from an attack by a partner or family member, you may be wondering whether self-defense can be used as a legal defense in your case. The answer is nuanced, but yes—self-defense can potentially be used in Florida domestic violence cases under specific circumstances.

Understanding Florida’s Self-Defense Laws

Florida’s self-defense statutes are among the most comprehensive in the nation, including the well-known “Stand Your Ground” law. The primary law governing self-defense in Florida is F.S. § 776.012, which establishes when a person is justified in using force to protect themselves or others.

Under this statute, a person is justified in using or threatening to use non-deadly force if they reasonably believe such force is necessary to defend themselves against another person’s imminent use of unlawful force. For deadly force, the standard is higher—it must be reasonably believed to be necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm.

The Unique Challenges of Self-Defense in Domestic Violence Cases

While self-defense is a recognized legal principle in Florida, asserting this defense in domestic violence cases presents unique challenges that defendants and their attorneys must carefully navigate.

The “He Said, She Said” Problem

Domestic violence incidents typically occur in private settings without independent witnesses. This creates what legal professionals often refer to as a “he said, she said” situation. Law enforcement officers arriving at the scene must make quick determinations based on limited information, often relying on visible injuries, the demeanor of the parties involved, and statements made at the scene.

Unfortunately, these initial assessments don’t always capture the full picture of what transpired. The person who initiated the violence may not show visible injuries, while the person who defended themselves may have caused more apparent harm in their efforts to protect themselves.

Societal and Legal Bias

Florida courts and law enforcement are rightfully sympathetic to victims of domestic violence, particularly given the serious nature of domestic abuse and its prevalence in our society. However, this sympathy can sometimes create an environment where self-defense claims are viewed with skepticism, especially when they come from defendants who caused visible injury to their alleged victims.

The Burden of Proof

The key to this defense, however, is being able to provide evidence of the imminent threat to prove that your actions were justified. This is particularly challenging in domestic violence cases where evidence may be limited and emotions are high.

Essential Elements of a Self-Defense Claim

To successfully assert self-defense in a Florida domestic violence case, several critical elements must be established:

1. Imminent Threat of Harm

The threat must be immediate and real, not speculative or based on future harm. You cannot claim self-defense against a threat that might materialize later or in response to verbal threats alone, unless those threats are accompanied by actions that create a reasonable fear of imminent physical harm.

2. Reasonable Belief of Necessity

Your belief that force was necessary to protect yourself must be reasonable under the circumstances. This is evaluated from the perspective of a reasonable person in your situation, considering factors such as the size and strength of the parties involved, any weapons present, and the history of violence in the relationship.

3. Proportional Response

The force used in self-defense must be proportional to the threat faced. You cannot use deadly force in response to a minor threat of non-deadly force. The response must be reasonable given the nature and severity of the threat.

4. No Provocation

Under Section 776.041, Florida Statutes, self-defense is not available where the defendant initially provoked the violence. If you started the physical confrontation or provoked the violence through your actions, claiming self-defense becomes much more difficult, though not impossible under certain circumstances.

Florida Statute § 776.041: When Self-Defense Is Limited

It’s crucial to understand that Florida Statute § 776.041 limits the availability of self-defense claims when the defendant provoked the violence. However, even if you initially provoked the confrontation, you may still be able to claim self-defense if: Continue reading

October 20, 2024

Importance of Evidence in Fort Lauderdale Domestic Violence Cases

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

Domestic violence charges are among the most serious criminal allegations one can face in Fort Lauderdale, often carrying severe legal and personal consequences. A conviction can lead to jail time, fines, mandatory counseling, loss of child custody, and even restrictions on where you can live or work. Because of the high stakes involved, building a strong defense is critical—and that defense often hinges on the quality and use of evidence.

As a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney, I have seen firsthand how evidence can make or break a Broward domestic violence case. Here, we’ll detail the different types of evidence that can be used in Florida domestic violence cases and discuss various defense strategies, as well as why it’s essential not to make any statements to the police unless or until your attorney is present.

Types of Evidence in Broward Domestic Violence Cases

Domestic violence cases can involve a variety of evidence, ranging from witness testimony to physical evidence. The more comprehensive and reliable the evidence, the stronger your defense can be. Here are some common types of evidence used in these cases:

Physical Evidence: This can include photographs of injuries, damaged property, or any objects used during an alleged incident. For example, bruises, cuts, or torn clothing may be presented by the prosecution as evidence of violence. However, defense attorneys can challenge the timing or cause of these injuries, showing that they may not have been the result of domestic violence.
Witness Testimony: Witnesses can include neighbors, friends, or even children who were present during the alleged incident. Their testimony can support either side’s version of events. In some cases, the alleged victim’s testimony might contradict earlier statements, which can be used to discredit the prosecution’s case.
Police Reports: When law enforcement arrives at the scene, they create a report detailing what they observed and the statements made by the parties involved. While this can be damaging evidence, police officers can make errors in their reports or misunderstand what took place, which a skilled defense attorney can point out during the trial.
911 Recordings: Calls to 911 are often used in domestic violence cases to establish the timeline of events and the urgency of the situation. However, these calls are made in the heat of the moment, and they may not fully or accurately reflect what occurred. A defense attorney can question the clarity and accuracy of these recordings.
Medical Records: If the alleged victim seeks medical treatment, their medical records may become part of the evidence. These records might show the extent of injuries, but they can also be used to demonstrate inconsistencies if the injuries do not align with the alleged events.
Character Evidence: In some cases, defense attorneys use character witnesses to show that the accused does not have a history of violence and is generally peaceful and responsible. This can be particularly useful in cases where the alleged victim’s credibility is in question.

Strategies for Building a Strong Defense

Building a robust defense in a Fort Lauderdale domestic violence case requires a thorough investigation and strategic use of evidence. Some useful strategies include: Continue reading

July 9, 2024

Fort Lauderdale Domestic Violence Attorney Details Most Effective Defenses

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

Fort Lauderdale domestic violence arrests are among the more common Broward County criminal offenses.

In a single recent year, there were more than 5,600 reported allegations of domestic violence in Broward – with 450 each from Fort Lauderdale and Hollywood Police Departments, according to FDLE.

But an allegation doesn’t equal an automatic arrest, and nor does an arrest equal an automatic conviction. You must take the charge seriously, of course, but the proof burden is on prosecutors — and domestic violence cases are notoriously tough to prosecute, particularly when the defendant has a good attorney. There are several strategies that can be employed by a highly-skilled Fort Lauderdale domestic violence attorney which have proven extremely effective in minimizing the fallout this will have to your life.

It Starts With Fact-Finding

To determine which strategy will be most effective, a Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyer is likely going to want to know more about:

Did the alleged victim have any wounds? If so, what was the nature of those wounds? Were they old or new? Were they examined by a medical doctor – and when?
Did you make any incriminating statements – to witnesses, to police, in jail, etc.? (We always urge clients as much as possible to ZIP IT – before, during, and after arrest. Defendants almost never explain their own way out of a jam. Let your attorney do the talking.)
Was there a 911 recording? Surveillance footage? Cell phone recordings? If so, to what extent does it undermine your case?
What was the condition of the scene when police arrived? Any evidence of a violent episode?
What was the emotional state of both parties when police arrived? Did either party appear intoxicated?
Does the accused have any history of violence, either toward the accuser or others?
What were the officer’s observations? Which version of events does it seem to support?

Once we have all this information, we’ll explore which domestic violence defense strategy makes the most sense for your Broward domestic violence charges.

Fort Lauderdale Domestic Violence Defense Strategies

August 1, 2023

Will Waiver of Prosecution Matter in Broward Domestic Violence Case?

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

Broward domestic violence cases often arise in the heat of the moment. Often by the next morning, both parties have cooled considerably and clearer heads prevail. It’s at this point the alleged victim may start looking into the possibility of signing a waiver of prosecution.

A waiver of prosecution, also sometimes called a declination of prosecution, is a sworn statement that informs the prosecutor, judge, and defense layer that they do not wish to prosecute or “press charges.”

The crux of this statement is basically two-fold:

The alleged victim formally states they do not want to press charges or cooperate with prosecutors.
The police report statements that were attributed to the alleged victim are either inaccurate or incomplete.

Sometimes, our Broward domestic violence defense lawyers are approached by the alleged victims of our clients to inquire about how they can go about getting the charges dismissed.

A few things we must outline for them at the start: Continue reading

July 15, 2023

Why Hiring a Broward Domestic Violence Defense Lawyer Early in Your Case is Key

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

If you’re arrested for domestic violence in Fort Lauderdale, the very best thing you can do to minimize the impact this will have on your life is to immediately hire a Broward domestic violence defense lawyer. Even if you’re “only” facing misdemeanor assault or battery charges, the classification of this crime as one of domestic violence has a whole host of implications that can result in immediate impact and long-term consequences far outside of the realm of a “typical” crime. When you work with a skilled domestic violence defense attorney right from the start, you’re not only better prepared, you can be proactive – possibly preventing some of the most significant penalties.

Domestic violence is defined in F.S. 741.28 as any assault, battery, sexual assault/battery, stalking, kidnapping, false imprisonment, or any other criminal offense that results in the physical injury or death of one family member/household member by another family/household member. These can be married couples, ex-married couples, people related by blood or marriage, people living together as a family, people who previously lived together as a family, and people who share a child together (regardless of whether they ever lived together or were married). Domestic violence charges will not apply to those who are dating, but have no kids and never lived together (though violence between them may still result in criminal charges).

But just because you’ve been arrested doesn’t necessarily mean the case is going to be successfully prosecuted. In fact, as an experienced Broward domestic violence defense lawyer, I can tell you prosecutors often have a tough time proving these accusations beyond a reasonable doubt. But knowing how to successfully challenge their evidence is essential. Some of the ways in which a skilled domestic violence defense attorney can help right from the start: Continue reading

October 28, 2022

Understanding Florida’s Domestic Violence Misdemeanor Diversion Program

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

When someone is facing a South Florida misdemeanor domestic violence charge, it’s worth exploring whether they qualify for a diversion program that would allow them to avoid a conviction.

As our Broward domestic violence defense lawyers can explain, not every defendant is going to qualify and it may not be the best strategic move for every case. But it’s important to discuss the possibility with your attorney.

What is a Domestic Violence Diversion Program?

A diversion program is a type of pre-trial intervention that essentially diverts the criminal case away from the usual track (which can end in conviction, jail, and fines) and instead allows qualifying defendants to complete educational courses and/or service requirements. When the program requirements are successfully met, the charges in the criminal case get dropped and the case is dismissed.

Some of the offenses that disqualify a defendant from a DV diversion program include:

Battery in which the defendant is accused of using substantial force to slap, punch, kick, or push an alleged victim to the ground.
Any battery that involves “degrading acts,” such as urinating or spitting on the alleged victim.
Any battery that involves alleged strangulation or choking of the victim.
Violations of domestic violence injunctions.

In general, domestic violence diversion program offenses are those involving minor intentional touching but don’t result in serious physical injury. If a defendant has a prior conviction or arrest for a felony as an adult, more than one misdemeanor adult conviction, or any prior domestic violence arrests, convictions, or pending charges, he or she will be ineligible for the domestic violence diversion program. No one is allowed to enter the diversion program more than once in their life.

It’s important to note that domestic violence charges – even those that are dropped due to a diversion program – generally cannot be sealed or expunged. Evidence of the arrest still shows up on your record. That’s why if there is a decent chance that your Broward domestic violence defense lawyer can successfully fight the charges against you, that may be in your best interests. But diversion programs can be an excellent alternative when there is a fair amount of evidence against you in a first-time, misdemeanor Florida domestic violence charge.

What to Expect in a Florida Domestic Violence Diversion Program

October 12, 2022

Fort Lauderdale Criminal Defense Lawyer Explains the Three Levels of Police Encounters

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

When Florida law enforcement officers interact with the public in the course of their duties, there are three levels of interaction that will dictate how any search or seizure in the course of that interaction will be judged from a legal perspective.

These three levels of interaction are:

Consensual encounters.
Detention or investigative stops.
Arrests.

Within each of these interactions, the person involved has constitutionally-protected rights. But those constitutional protections are different at each level. If those rights are violated, then it is more likely that your Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyer will have some success in convincing the court to suppress evidence gleaned in that interaction. Here, we review the rights and protections at each level.

Consensual Encounters

Consensual encounters with police in Florida don’t require officers to establish any sort of evidence of wrongdoing. There’s no bright line rule for when an encounter is consensual vs. investigative, but we can say that a key aspect of consensual police encounters is that the person at the center of the interaction is free to leave.

The lines can get a little fuzzy because courts have held that law enforcement is allowed during a consensual encounter to ask you questions, ask to see your ID, might even ask to search your vehicle. If they say or imply that complying with their requests is mandatory, then it’s no longer a consensual encounter. However, police encounters can often be intimidating and people sometimes feel they don’t have much of a choice – even when they do. If you consent to answer questions or to be searched during a consensual encounter, it can be difficult to challenge any evidence gleaned from that – because you freely agreed to it. You’re often better off keeping your answers brief, politely declining any requests to search, and asking point blank whether you’re free to go.

In determining whether a police interaction began with a consensual encounter (as opposed to an investigative stop), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in the 1980 case of U.S. v. Mendenhall that courts should examine the totality of circumstances – and specifically, whether a reasonable person believed themselves free to go. Continue reading

November 15, 2021

What to Know if You’re Facing Fort Lauderdale Domestic Violence Battery Charges

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

Domestic violence allegations are taken very seriously by authorities in South Florida. If you’re arrested for domestic violence battery, you must take the charges seriously and quickly “lawyer up” if you hope to avoid the most significant penalties and long-term consequences. Hiring a lawyer is not an indicator of guilt, but rather can help mitigate the impact of the charges on your life – particularly your job and future opportunities, as well as your right to bear arms.

Those accused may not be inclined to concern themselves much about unfounded accusations, presuming it’ll all be sorted out fairly in court. But as our Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyers can explain, cultural forces have imposed increasing pressure on law enforcement agencies and prosecutors increasingly to make arrests and secure convictions in domestic violence cases. The truth may not be enough to set you free. What will is immediate legal advice from a knowledgeable, experienced South Florida domestic violence attorney.

What is Domestic Violence Battery in Florida?

According to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, there were approximately 105,000 reported Florida domestic violence arrests in a single recent year. Per F.S. 741.49, officers responding to an alleged report of domestic violence who decide not to arrest anyone are required to provide reasons why they chose not to arrest anyone.

State law defines domestic violence as any means of assault, aggravated assault, battery, aggravated battery, sexual assault, sexual battery, stalking, aggravated stalking, kidnapping, false imprisonment, or any other criminal offense resulting in physical injury or death of one family member, household member, former romantic partner, or co-parent against another. Domestic violence battery involves the intentional and actual touching or striking of another individual without their consent or the intentional infliction of bodily harm. It is typically charged as a first-degree misdemeanor, which is the highest level of misdemeanor with a penalty of up to 12 months in jail and/or 12 months of probation, as well as a maximum fine of $1,000. The law further stipulates that if injury resulted, there is a five day minimum mandatory jail term, plus a mandatory 29-week batterer’s intervention program. It’s considered a deportable offense by immigration services. It will result in the revocation of any concealed weapons permits, and the forfeiture of any guns while on probation – even for misdemeanor battery charges. No contact orders or injunctions may be imposed. There could be adverse impacts on the child custody/parenting time order. Community service may also be ordered. You may be barred from certain types of employment and housing in the future, as your record will always be visible; domestic violence charges can never be expunged or sealed, even if adjudication is withheld. You may be barred from obtaining certain types of loans and security clearance if you’re convicted. Continue reading

November 20, 2016

Domestic Violence Arrest in Florida for Girlfriend of FIU Tight End in Alleged Boiling Water Attack

By The Law Offices of Richard Ansara, P.A.

A senior at Florida International University who played on the football team’s tight end was reportedly the victim of a domestic violence attack that has ended his career.

The Miami Herald reports the Panthers’ 2017 NFL Draft prospect suffered severe burns on his head, neck, back, arm and shoulder after his girlfriend reportedly dumped boiling water on top of him. The woman, Mary Gaspar, 20, is reportedly five months pregnant with Jonnu Smith’s child, and has been charge with a single count of aggravated battery. Gaspar is also a student at the school, a junior who lives on campus.

The couple were reportedly arguing in Smith’s dorm when defendant is alleged to have boiled the water and walked over and poured it on top of Smith. She reported she was livid over Smith’s failure to attend to their relationship and was feeling extremely stressed out and emotional. When Smith reportedly did not act strongly enough to the boiled water on his skin, Gaspar allegedly started to strike him with her fists. Continue reading